The Traitors: Prepare for Chaos – Season 4’s Killer Cast Revealed | popgeeks.com

The Traitors US Season 4 Cast Reveal: A Gathering of Suspects and Sleuths

The stage is set for The Traitors US Season 4, where a fresh crop of reality TV luminaries and unexpected faces will descend upon the Scottish castle, each hoping to avoid a “murder” or “banishment” as they navigate a treacherous game of deception. This season promises a macabre blend of strategic gameplay and dramatic unmasking, with a cast diverse enough to be either cunning culprits or sharp-witted detectives. The show is expected to premiere in early 2026, following the pattern of previous seasons, and is currently in production. Who will survive the night, and who will meet their untimely demise?

The Traitors Season 4 Cast: Potential Traitors and Faithfuls

Natalie Anderson (The Amazing Race, Survivor)

• Past Reality TV: Natalie is a highly decorated reality TV veteran, a true survivor of multiple strategic battlegrounds. She first appeared with her twin sister Nadiya on “The Amazing Race 21” (2012), then again on “The Amazing Race: All-Stars” (2014). Her most significant achievements are on “Survivor: San Juan del Sur” (2014), where she won the million-dollar prize, and “Survivor: Winners at War” (2020), where she fought her way back from the Edge of Extinction to become the runner-up. She also tested her mettle on “The Challenge: Double Agents.”
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Excellent Traitor material. Natalie has proven she can wield the dagger with precision. Her Survivor career demonstrates a keen strategic mind, a willingness to make bold, deceptive moves, and exceptional composure under pressure. She’s navigated countless blindsides and shown a ruthless competitive drive, making her a prime candidate to pull off the ultimate deception as a Traitor. As a Faithful, she’d be a formidable hunter, sniffing out shady dealings from a mile away.

Yamil “Yam Yam” Arocho (Survivor)

• Past Reality TV: Yam Yam charmed his way to victory on “Survivor 44” (2023), becoming a fan-favorite for his charismatic and social gameplay. He was a key part of the dominant Tika alliance, known for their unbreakable bonds and surprising strategic acumen. In pre-game interviews, Yam Yam famously attributed his strong social skills and ability to gather information to his experience working in a beauty salon, which he described as a hub for gossip – perfect training for unmasking secrets.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Strong Faithful material, but potential as a Traitor. Yam Yam’s social grace makes him a natural leader for the Faithfuls, capable of rallying votes and uncovering deceit. His beauty salon background has honed his observational skills, allowing him to discern truth from whispers. However, his natural charm could also make him a highly effective Traitor, effortlessly gaining trust before delivering a fatal blow in the dead of night.

Mark Ballas (Dancing with the Stars)

• Past Reality TV: Mark is a professional dancer and choreographer best known for his long tenure on “Dancing with the Stars” (2007-2022), where he won the Mirrorball Trophy three times.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Likely Faithful material. Mark’s expertise lies in performance and physical challenge, not typically the dark arts of social manipulation or strategic sabotage. He’ll likely be an amiable and trustworthy Faithful, perhaps more concerned with smooth steps than cloak and dagger operations. His competitive drive might make him a determined investigator, but probably not the mastermind.

Candiace Dillard Bassett (Real Housewives of Potomac)

• Past Reality TV: Candiace is a main cast member of “The Real Housewives of Potomac” (2018-2024), known for her sharp wit, dramatic confrontations, and musical career. Before Housewives, she was Miss United States 2013.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Strong Traitor material. Candiace is articulate, intelligent, and famously unafraid to speak her mind, which can be an asset for a Traitor creating diversions. Her Housewives history shows she can navigate complex social dynamics and engage in strategic verbal sparring, often leaving her adversaries in a rhetorical graveyard. Her outspokenness could serve as a great cover if she were a Traitor; people might dismiss her clever accusations as merely “being Candiace.”

Ron Funches (comedian)

• Past Reality TV: While primarily known as a stand-up comedian, actor, and voice artist, Ron has no prior competitive reality TV experience, nor has he been a primary cast member on a reality show.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Potentially a wildcard, leaning Faithful. Comedians often excel at reading people and diffusing tension, which could make Ron a good Faithful who can unite groups or spot subtle cues. However, his laid-back and humorous persona could also be a surprisingly effective cover for a Traitor, as people might dismiss his cleverness as just a joke, not a dagger.

Rob Cesternino (Survivor)

• Past Reality TV: Rob is a two-time contestant on “Survivor”, first appearing on “Survivor: Amazon” (2003) and then “Survivor: All-Stars” (2004). On Survivor: Amazon, he earned the unfortunate distinction of being called the “best player to never win.” Tragically for him, in Survivor: All-Stars, he never even reached the merge, falling victim to the deceptive prowess of Boston Rob Mariano. He almost competed in Survivor: Blood vs. Water, but his wife Nicole became pregnant, altering his fate. After his appearances, he became a highly successful podcaster, known as the “Rob Has a Podcast” (RHAP) founder, where he meticulously analyzes numerous reality shows, including Survivor, Big Brother, and, of course, The Traitors.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Exceptional Traitor or Faithful material. Rob is a master strategist who has spent years dissecting the mechanics of social deduction games. He understands the meta-game better than almost anyone, having analyzed countless player decisions and “murder” patterns. This makes him extraordinarily dangerous as a Traitor (he’d know exactly how to play the long game and deflect suspicion) and a highly effective Faithful (he’d be analyzing every interaction for tells, likely leading the charge in the war against the Traitors). The anecdote of a disappointed fan at a meet-and-greet calling him “Rob that sucks” because they were expecting Boston Rob is particularly telling. If Cesternino outlasts Boston Rob in The Traitors, it will be the sweetest revenge story the castle has ever seen.

Monét X Change (RuPaul’s Drag Race)

• Past Reality TV: Monét is a prominent drag queen who competed on “RuPaul’s Drag Race” Season 10 (2018), finishing 6th and winning Miss Congeniality. She later returned for “RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars 4” (2018-2019), which she co-won, and “RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars 7: All Winners” (2022), where she was a runner-up.

• Traitor or Faithful Material: Excellent Traitor material. Monét is highly intelligent, quick-witted, and has shown a strong strategic mind, particularly in the “All Stars” formats which involve more social game. She’s a self-professed super-fan of Survivor and Big Brother, indicating a deep understanding of social deduction and strategic gameplay. Her charm and ability to entertain could also serve as a great cover for a Traitor, distracting from her true intentions.

  Can Monét Break the “Drag Queen Curse?” There’s a noticeable pattern: previous Drag Race contestants on The Traitors (Peppermint, Bob the Drag Queen, Melinda Verga) have often faced early banishment or murder. This has led to speculation about a “drag queen curse,” perhaps due to their bold personalities being misinterpreted as inherently suspicious in a game where subtlety is often key. However, Monét X Change has a strong chance to defy this trend. Her strategic acumen, proven in Drag Race All Stars, and her deep understanding of social strategy games (as a self-professed Survivor and Big Brother super-fan) equip her uniquely for The Traitors. She possesses the intelligence and ability to be both charismatic and subtly strategic, making her a formidable player whether she’s a Faithful hunting Traitors or a Traitor herself. She might be the one to break the curse and leave the others in the dust, or rather, the graveyard.

Stephen Colletti (Laguna Beach, One Tree Hill)

• Past Reality TV: Stephen first gained fame on the MTV reality series “Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County” (2004-2005). After that, he transitioned into acting, most notably appearing on “One Tree Hill” (2007-2012). He co-hosts a podcast revisiting “Laguna Beach.”
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful material. Stephen’s background is more in dramatic reality and scripted television than cutthroat strategic competition. He’s likely to be a genuine and trustworthy Faithful, perhaps more prone to trusting faces than scrutinizing motives. His charm might help him build alliances as a Faithful, but he may lack the innate deceptive qualities needed to wield the Traitor’s power.

Maura Higgins (Love Island)

• Past Reality TV: Maura is best known for her appearance on “Love Island” UK Season 5 (2019), where she was a popular and outspoken contestant. She finished 4th. She has since appeared on other UK reality shows like “Dancing on Ice” and “Shopping with Keith Lemon.”
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Potential wildcard, leaning Faithful. Maura’s direct and often fiery personality from Love Island could make her a strong Faithful who speaks her mind and challenges suspected Traitors head-on. She might not have a natural inclination for subtle deception, making her an unlikely killer. However, her willingness to be dramatic and her outspokenness could also be used as a smokescreen if she were chosen to be a Traitor.

Donna Kelce (Jason and Travis Kelce’s mom)

• Past Reality TV: Donna Kelce is not a traditional reality TV star. She gained widespread public recognition as the beloved mother of NFL stars Jason Kelce and Travis Kelce, especially during the 2023 Super Bowl when her sons played against each other. Her profile was further elevated due to her son Travis’s high-profile relationship with music icon Taylor Swift, which has brought her into the global spotlight. She has no prior competitive reality TV experience, nor has she been a primary cast member on a reality show.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Likely Faithful material. Donna’s public persona is one of a supportive, beloved matriarch. This perception would make her highly trusted by other Faithfuls, making her an unsuspecting target for a Traitor. It would be a surprising and potentially brilliant move to make her a Traitor, as no one would ever suspect the sweet football mom. However, without a background in strategic games, she’d likely be a genuine and observant Faithful, hoping to see the Traitors caught red-handed.

Kristen Kish (Top Chef)

• Past Reality TV: Kristen is a celebrated chef who won “Top Chef” Season 10 (2012). She has since become a prominent culinary figure, hosting various cooking shows and is now the host of Top Chef.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful material, but with strategic potential. Kristen is known for her calm demeanor and sharp culinary skills, which require precision and strategic planning – useful traits for detective work. While “Top Chef” is a competitive show, its focus is on culinary creation rather than social deception. She might be a methodical and observant Faithful, capable of picking up on subtle cues. If she were a Traitor, her calm and collected nature could make her very difficult to read, a quiet killer.

Tara Lipinski (Olympic figure skater)

• Past Reality TV: Tara is an Olympic gold medalist in figure skating (1998 Nagano Olympics). Since retiring, she has become a prominent sports commentator, often working with fellow Olympian Johnny Weir. She has no prior competitive reality TV experience as a contestant.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Likely Faithful material. Tara’s background is in individual athletic competition, requiring discipline and focus, not social manipulation. She’s likely to be a straightforward and trustworthy Faithful, bringing an earnest determination to identify the Traitors. She’s less likely to be involved in shady dealings and more likely to call them out.

Dorinda Medley (Real Housewives of New York City)

• Past Reality TV: Dorinda is known for her tenure on “The Real Housewives of New York City” (2015-2021). She previously appeared on “The Traitors” US Season 3 (2024), where she was the first Faithful to be “murdered” by the Traitors.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Interesting Traitor or Faithful material. Having been a first murder victim, Dorinda has direct, painful experience with the Faithful’s vulnerability. This could make her a very determined Faithful, obsessed with vengeance against the Traitors, or, conversely, a very strategic Traitor who knows how the game feels from the other side, and how to avoid being a victim. Her outspoken and sometimes combative personality might make her appear less trustworthy to some, regardless of her role, putting a permanent finger of suspicion on her.

Tiffany Mitchell (Big Brother)

• Past Reality TV: Tiffany is a fan-favorite from “Big Brother 23” (2021), where she was a part of the iconic “Cookout” alliance and was known for her strategic prowess and her ability to manipulate multiple alliances. She finished 6th and won America’s Favorite Houseguest.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Exceptional Traitor or Faithful material. Tiffany is a highly intelligent and strategic player from Big Brother, a game centered on social manipulation, alliances, and, crucially, deception. She excels at building relationships while secretly strategizing. She would be a masterful Traitor, able to weave intricate webs of deceit, making her a true master of deception. As a Faithful, her observational skills and understanding of social dynamics would make her a formidable Traitor hunter, capable of slicing through lies.

Eric Nam (singer)

• Past Reality TV: Eric Nam is a popular Korean-American singer, songwriter, and television personality. While he has hosted and appeared on various Korean reality/variety shows, he has no prior competitive English-language reality TV experience as a contestant.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Potential wildcard, leaning Faithful. Eric’s charm and likability could make him a well-trusted Faithful, a calming presence in the chaos. His background as a host and personality means he’s adept at social interaction and reading a room. If he’s a Traitor, his generally friendly demeanor could be an excellent disguise, allowing him to operate in the shadows, unsuspected.

Michael Rapaport (actor)

• Past Reality TV: Michael Rapaport is a well-known actor with a long career in film and television. He competed on “The Celebrity Apprentice” (2012) where he was fired in week 10. He is primarily an actor and has not been a regular cast member on a non-competitive reality series.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful, but with potential for chaos. Michael is known for his outspoken, sometimes volatile personality. As a Faithful, he might be quick to accuse and cause arguments, which can be both helpful and detrimental in identifying Traitors, or simply lead to more confusion and bodies piling up. As a Traitor, his strong personality could either be a good smoke screen or quickly make him a target, his fatal flaw potentially being his inability to be subtle.

Rob Rausch (Love Island USA)

• Past Reality TV: Rob appeared on “Love Island USA” Season 5 (2023) and is making a return to the show for Season 6. He is famously known as a snake wrangler.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful material. Love Island is a social game focused on relationships, but not deception in the same way as The Traitors. His “snake wrangler” profession could be a fun, ironic touch, but likely doesn’t translate to a strategic advantage in identifying human snakes. He’s likely to be a genuine and trusting Faithful, potentially a bit naive to the deeper strategic plays, making him an easy target for Traitors.

Lisa Rinna (Real Housewives of Beverly Hills)

• Past Reality TV: Lisa is an iconic cast member of “The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” (2014-2022), known for her dramatic confrontations and her catchphrase “own it.” She also competed on “The Celebrity Apprentice 4” (2011) and “All-Star Celebrity Apprentice” (2013).
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Strong Traitor material. Lisa’s Housewives tenure proves her willingness to engage in conflict and manipulate narratives, “owning” her role, however nefarious. She’s a performer who can embody any character, which would serve a Traitor well. Her experience on Celebrity Apprentice means she understands game mechanics and how to play to win. She could easily convince others she’s a Faithful while secretly orchestrating murders, her smile hiding a sinister plot.

Caroline Stanbury (Real Housewives of Dubai)

• Past Reality TV: Caroline was a main cast member on “Ladies of London” (2014-2017) before moving to Dubai and joining “The Real Housewives of Dubai” (2022-2024). She is known for her luxurious lifestyle and strong opinions.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Traitor material. Caroline is sophisticated and strategically minded in her social interactions. Her Housewives background shows she can be calculating and form alliances to her advantage, always with an eye on the prize. She presents herself as very direct and honest, which could be a superb cover for a Traitor, allowing her to operate under a veneer of trustworthiness.

Ian Terry (Big Brother)

• Past Reality TV: Ian is a winner of “Big Brother 14” (2012) and also appeared on “Big Brother: All-Stars” (2020). He is known for his analytical mind, strategic thinking, and quirky personality.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Excellent Faithful material, but could be a surprising Traitor. Ian is a Big Brother winner, a game that demands high-level strategic thinking, alliance building, and social manipulation. He’s incredibly intelligent and would likely be a formidable Faithful, dissecting every clue and performing forensic-level detective work. If chosen as a Traitor, his seemingly innocent and somewhat awkward demeanor could make him exceptionally dangerous, the quiet assassin no one sees coming. His analytical approach makes him a strong asset regardless of his role.

Colton Underwood (The Bachelor)

• Past Reality TV: Colton rose to fame as a contestant on “The Bachelorette” (2018) and then as the lead of “The Bachelor” (2019). He later came out publicly as gay.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful material. While The Bachelor franchise involves social dynamics, it’s not a game of deception in the same way as The Traitors. Colton’s public image has often been defined by his personal journey and revelations rather than strategic gameplay. He’s likely to be a trusting and earnest Faithful, possibly making him an easy mark for a manipulative Traitor.

Johnny Weir (Olympic figure skater)

• Past Reality TV: Johnny is an Olympic figure skater (2006, 2010 Winter Olympics) and a World bronze medalist. After retiring from competitive skating, he became a prominent and flamboyant sports commentator, often alongside Tara Lipinski. He has no prior competitive reality TV experience as a contestant.
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Leaning Faithful material. Similar to Tara Lipinski, Johnny’s competitive background is in individual sport, not social strategy or the art of the lie. His flamboyant persona could be a distraction in the game, drawing attention away from the real culprits, but he’s likely to be a genuine and open Faithful.

Porsha Williams (Real Housewives of Atlanta)

• Past Reality TV: Porsha is a long-standing cast member of “The Real Housewives of Atlanta” (2012-2021, rejoined 2024), known for her dramatic flair and strong personality. She has also starred in spin-off series like “Porsha’s Family Matters.”
• Traitor or Faithful Material: Strong Traitor material. Porsha is charismatic, assertive, and has years of experience navigating complex group dynamics and conflicts on Real Housewives. She can be very persuasive and has shown a willingness to be aggressive in her confrontations, which could be extremely useful for a Traitor trying to deflect suspicion or sow discord among Faithfuls, creating chaos for her own dark purposes.

The Traitors Season 4: Who Knows Whom: Pre-Existing Alliances (or Suspects)

In the shadowy halls of The Traitors castle, pre-existing relationships can be either a source of unshakeable trust or the first crack in a carefully constructed facade. Several connections already exist within this cast, primarily due to shared franchises or past appearances:

• Real Housewives Franchise: The largest obvious contingent.
  • Dorinda Medley (RHONY), Candiace Dillard Bassett (RHOP), Lisa Rinna (RHOBH), Caroline Stanbury (RHODubai), and Porsha Williams (RHOA) all hail from different installments of “The Real Housewives.” They’ve likely crossed paths at Bravo events, on “Watch What Happens Live,” or through the extensive Housewives ecosystem. This shared experience might give them a common understanding of social games, but also a pre-set level of skepticism for each other’s dramatic flair.
• Survivor Veterans: A formidable strategic bloc.
  • Natalie Anderson, Yam Yam Arocho, and Rob Cesternino are all from “Survivor.” Rob Cesternino, in particular, will know both Natalie and Yam Yam’s games intimately through his “Rob Has a Podcast” analyses and interviews. This could create a very interesting dynamic: will they form a strong, strategic “Survivor alliance” that dominates the game, or will their deep knowledge of each other’s past betrayals lead to immediate, intense suspicion?
• Big Brother Veterans: Masters of the social game.
  • Tiffany Mitchell and Ian Terry are both “Big Brother” winners/notable players. They’ve honed their skills in a game centered on social strategy, alliance work, and deception. They are highly likely to connect and try to work together, bringing a similar, high-level strategic mindset to the castle’s investigation.
• Olympic Figure Skaters: A pair of poised partners.
  • Tara Lipinski and Johnny Weir are long-time friends and professional commentary partners. They will undoubtedly have a very strong bond and trust each other implicitly. This could make them a powerful mini-alliance for the Faithfuls, or a surprisingly strategic duo if one (or both!) were chosen as a Traitor, able to glide through accusations.
• Former “Apprentice” Contestants: Boardroom battle-tested.
  • Lisa Rinna and Michael Rapaport both competed on “The Celebrity Apprentice” (though different seasons). They share an experience with a different kind of reality competition, which might give them common ground for initial alliances.
• Bachelor Nation: The solitary romantic.
  • Colton Underwood is the sole representative from “The Bachelor” franchise in this group, likely entering the castle without any pre-existing alliances.

These pre-existing relationships will undoubtedly shape alliances, trust levels, and the direction of the “finger of suspicion” from the very beginning of The Traitors Season 4. The hunt for the truth, or the perfect lie, begins!